The Edge Blog · Legal & Compliance · July 2, 2024 · 7 min read

ADA Compliance in Commercial Properties: Owner and Tenant Responsibilities

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) revolutionized accessibility when it was signed into law in 1990, mandating that people with disabilities have equal access to public accommodations and commercial facilities. Yet more than three decades later,…

For property owners and tenants alike, understanding ADA responsibilities isn't just about avoiding lawsuits—though that's certainly important given the rise in accessibility litigation. It's about creating spaces that welcome all potential customers, employees, and visitors, expanding your business's reach while fulfilling important civil rights obligations.

Understanding the ADA's Reach in Commercial Real Estate

The ADA's accessibility requirements primarily affect commercial properties through Title III, which covers public accommodations and commercial facilities. This includes virtually all businesses open to the public: retail stores, restaurants, professional offices, hotels, theaters, and more.

What many don't realize is that ADA compliance isn't a one-time achievement but an ongoing obligation that evolves with your property and changes in regulations. When the Department of Justice updated the ADA Standards for Accessible Design in 2010, it created new compliance requirements for existing facilities, not just new construction.

According to the U.S. Department of Justice, ADA compliance in commercial properties generally falls into three categories:

New construction must be fully accessible, incorporating all applicable accessibility standards from the ground up.
Alterations to existing facilities must comply with accessibility standards to the maximum extent feasible.
Existing facilities must remove architectural barriers where such removal is "readily achievable," – defined as easily accomplishable without significant difficulty or expense.

This tiered approach creates different standards for different properties, acknowledging that retrofitting historical buildings for complete accessibility may not always be practicable.

The Dividing Line: Owner vs. Tenant Responsibilities

Perhaps the most contentious aspect of ADA compliance is determining who bears responsibility – the property owner or the tenant. The answer, like many legal questions, is: it depends.

The lease document typically serves as the starting point for allocating ADA obligations. Many commercial leases explicitly address which party assumes responsibility for various compliance aspects. When leases remain silent on ADA issues, courts generally look to which party controls the non-compliant area.

Common areas – parking lots, entrances, lobbies, elevators, and shared restrooms – typically remain under landlord control and therefore landlord responsibility. Interior tenant spaces generally fall under tenant responsibility, particularly regarding operational aspects and readily achievable barrier removal.

This division creates a practical challenge: neither party can ensure complete compliance without cooperation from the other. A perfectly accessible tenant space means little if customers cannot access the building entrance. Conversely, an accessible building with inaccessible tenant spaces fails to fulfill the ADA's purpose.

Landlord Responsibilities: Beyond the Common Areas

Property owners bear primary responsibility for the physical accessibility of their building's structure, common areas, and shared facilities. This includes providing accessible entrances, elevators, restrooms, drinking fountains, and parking.

For new construction and major renovations, landlords must ensure compliance with current ADA standards. This includes appropriate door widths, accessible routes throughout common areas, compliant restroom facilities, and proper signage.

For existing buildings, landlords must remove barriers when readily achievable. According to The ADA National Network, readily achievable barrier removal often includes installing ramps, creating accessible parking spaces, widening doorways, and installing grab bars in restrooms.

Importantly, landlords cannot shift all compliance burdens to tenants through lease provisions. Courts have consistently held that landlords retain ultimate responsibility for common area accessibility, regardless of lease language attempting to transfer those obligations.

Tenant Responsibilities: Creating Accessible Experiences

Commercial tenants bear responsibility for ensuring their specific business operations comply with ADA standards. This extends beyond physical accessibility to include policies, practices, and procedures that accommodate individuals with disabilities.

Within leased spaces, tenants generally must ensure accessible routes throughout the premises, appropriate counter heights, adequate maneuvering space, and removal of barriers that restrict access to goods and services. For retail operations, this might include maintaining accessible paths between display fixtures. For restaurants, it means providing accessible seating options throughout the establishment.

Operational compliance responsibilities include providing auxiliary aids and services when necessary for effective communication. Depending on the business type, this might involve offering materials in alternative formats, providing assistive listening devices, or ensuring staff assistance is available.

Service animal accommodation falls squarely within tenant responsibilities. Under the ADA guidelines, businesses must modify policies to permit service animals in customer areas, regardless of normal "no pets" policies.

Navigating the Gray Areas: Tenant Improvements and Alterations

Tenant improvement projects create particularly complex compliance scenarios. When tenants renovate leased spaces, both parties typically share certain ADA obligations.

Tenants generally bear responsibility for ensuring their improvement projects meet current ADA standards. This might include installing accessible restrooms within the tenant space, ensuring proper aisle widths, and providing accessible counters and work surfaces.

Landlords, meanwhile, often remain responsible for ensuring tenant improvements don't compromise accessibility in common areas or create non-compliant elements that will remain after the tenant vacates. Many sophisticated landlords require ADA compliance certification from tenants completing improvement projects.

The challenge intensifies when tenant improvements require modifications to building systems or structural elements. For instance, if a restaurant tenant needs additional restrooms that require core drilling through structural slabs, the landlord typically must ensure those modifications don't compromise the building's structural integrity or accessibility.

The Compliance Partnership: Best Practices for Both Parties

Given the shared nature of ADA compliance, a collaborative approach between landlords and tenants typically yields the best results.

Property owners should conduct professional accessibility audits of common areas and provide tenants with information about known compliance issues. Addressing these issues proactively, rather than waiting for complaints or litigation, demonstrates good faith and often proves less expensive in the long run.

Clearly defining ADA responsibilities in lease documents benefits both parties. Rather than general statements about "compliance with applicable laws," specific provisions detailing which party handles particular aspects of accessibility create clarity and reduce disputes.

Tenants should evaluate potential spaces for accessibility before leasing. Identifying significant barriers upfront allows for negotiation of responsibility for corrections before signing the lease. This might include securing landlord commitments to address specific issues or rent concessions to offset tenant compliance costs.

For multi-tenant properties, landlords and tenants benefit from establishing communication protocols for addressing accessibility complaints. This ensures prompt response to legitimate concerns before they escalate to litigation.

The Cost of Non-Compliance: Legal and Financial Risks

The consequences of failing to meet ADA obligations extend far beyond the moral implications of excluding people with disabilities. They include significant legal and financial exposure for both owners and tenants.

ADA lawsuits have increased dramatically in recent years, with thousands filed annually. These cases typically seek injunctive relief (requiring modification to remove barriers) plus attorneys' fees, which often exceed the cost of the modifications themselves.

Beyond formal litigation, businesses face potential investigation by the Department of Justice, which can result in civil penalties reaching $150,000 for first violations. These investigations can be triggered by individual complaints, even without a lawsuit.

The financial impact extends beyond legal expenses. Non-compliant properties typically command lower rents, face higher vacancy rates, and experience more challenging refinancing terms. Meanwhile, businesses operating in non-compliant spaces lose an estimated $750 billion in annual purchasing power from people with disabilities and their families.

Moving Forward: The Proactive Approach to Compliance

Rather than viewing ADA compliance as merely a legal obligation, forward-thinking property owners and tenants recognize it as a business opportunity. Creating truly accessible spaces expands your potential customer base while demonstrating corporate social responsibility.

The most effective approach combines professional guidance, clear communication, and ongoing attention. Regular property assessments help identify emerging issues before they generate complaints. Periodic staff training ensures operational compliance. An open dialogue between landlords and tenants creates a foundation for addressing concerns collaboratively rather than adversarially.

At CENTURY 21 Edge, our commercial specialists help both property owners and tenants navigate ADA requirements with confidence. We can connect you with qualified accessibility consultants, recommend experienced contractors for modification projects, and help structure lease agreements that clearly delineate compliance responsibilities.

Remember that ADA compliance isn't just about avoiding litigation—it's about creating spaces where everyone can participate fully in commercial life. When approached thoughtfully, accessibility benefits not just people with disabilities, but the entire business community.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.

#Article

ShareFacebook X LinkedIn Email