5753 NEW YORK AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL, 34231
Active4118 days on marketMLS #A4121629
About this home
5753 NEW YORK AVENUE
Fully turnkey Now offered Annually for $3500.00 , 6-12 months at agreed upon rental price depending on length and time of year. or High Season 3 month min. Dec-April at $5500.00 Rentals over 6 months and longer pay all utilities. TV ,Internet and a monthly Electric amount provided by the owner for rentals under 6 months .Charming pet friendly pool home in a great location near shopping and Siesta Key Beach. 3 bedroom,2 bath single family home overlooking a large screened- in private pool Master bedroom has a King size bed and newly remodeled en -suite Bath. Guest bedroom has a Queen size bed and 3rd bedroom has 2 twin beds. Guest bath has a tub and shower .Full size washer, dryer . Enjoy this private retreat. Less than 5 miles to world famous Siesta Key , I-75 ,restaurants and shopping .! Pool and spa are heated ,no jets in the spa. Pool and grounds maintenance included. Garage is NOT included. Pets welcome with a Non-refundable pet fee.
Facts & features
The home at a glance
3
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,358
Sqft
0.17 ac
Lot size
1996
Year built
One
Levels
$4
Per sqft
Inside
Outside & construction
Community & fees
Utilities & systems
The numbers
What it really costs
Built from this home's actual numbers — the most recent property-tax bill on record — not generic estimates.
$483 /mo · 3.5% down FHA, 30-yr fixed at 6%
The assumptions
FHA is the default here because it gets you in the door with just 3.5% down. Switch to Conventional or VA below.
These numbers assume a generic buyer — your credit, down payment and loan program change them. Get the real quote in minutes:
Andrew Acosta
Acosta Home Loans with PRMG · NMLS #1468866
Run your own numbers
Estimated payment
$483/mo
Includes FHA mortgage insurance and the financed 1.75% upfront premium. Taxes reflect the most recent bill on record; insurance is a typical-Florida estimate. Your lender’s numbers will differ. CENTURY 21 Edge partners with Florida’s best lenders.
Value check
Is the price right?
The internet’s favorite home-value number comes from a single automated model that has never seen the street, the finishes, or the view — which is why it routinely misses by tens of thousands of dollars. The edgeAI estimate combines multiple independent data sources with our team’s on-the-ground expertise in this exact market.
$/sqft vs Sarasota actives
$4 vs $349
Days on market
4118 vs 64 typical
Where $4/sqft sits among the 400 Sarasota actives
The edgeAI estimate is a starting point, not an appraisal or a broker price opinion. It is generated from public records, listing data and market modeling, and is subject to change once a licensed real estate professional personally inspects the property. Condition, floor, view and lot are not fully captured by any model — ask us for a full comparative market analysis.
Where it sits
Inside Sarasota
Drive times from this address
Estimated driving times, typical traffic. Data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Get to know Sarasota. See the full Sarasota guide →
SARASOTA 34231 — neighborhood snapshot
Population
32,203
Median age
55.1
Median income
$69,721
Median home value
$363,400
Avg household
2.03
Households w/ children
2,803
For the school run
Sarasota County School District
School assignments and ratings via edgeAI — always verify with the district.
The numbers that matter
The Sarasota market
$475K → $493K
Sarasota median sold, yr/yr
95.2%
Sale-to-list ratio (12 mo)
169 of 400
Sarasota actives have cut their price
Median sold price, Sarasota, trailing 36 months (3-month rolling) · live MLS data.
This home is listed 97% below the SARASOTA 34231 median. See the full Sarasota market guide →
Paper trail
This home's history
Reality check
What actually sold near 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE
Asking prices are opinions — closed sales are facts. The most comparable homes that actually changed hands nearby in the last twelve months.
Sold · Jul ’26$230,000
7145 BRIGHT CREEK DRIVE UNIT 33
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,352 sqft · $170/sqft · 33 DOM
Sold · Mar ’26$265,000
7205 WOOD CREEK DRIVE UNIT 16
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,340 sqft · $198/sqft · 273 DOM
Sold · Jul ’26$422,500
7113 ANTIGUA PLACE
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,378 sqft · $307/sqft · 12 DOM
Closed-sale data from the MLS, last 12 months, selected for similarity in size and location. No two homes are identical — ask us for a full comparative analysis.
Your home team
The pros in your corner
Buying a home is two conversations — the home and the money. Here’s who handles each, side by side, already working together.
Your agent
Krystina Allen
Real Estate Agent · CENTURY 21 Edge
Tours, negotiation, and every question about 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE — start here.
Your lender
Andrew Acosta
Acosta Home Loans with PRMG · NMLS #1468866
Pre-approval, rates, and the real monthly number for 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE — before you fall in love.
See it in person
Schedule a tour
Live availability from Krystina's calendar — pick a time and it's booked. Confirmation lands in your inbox immediately.
Straight answers
5753 NEW YORK AVENUE FAQs
What would the monthly payment be for 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE?+
With 3.5% down on a 30-year FHA loan at 6%, the all-in payment lands around $483/mo — principal and interest, the actual property-tax bill and typical Florida insurance. The payment calculator on this page lets you switch loan type (FHA, Conventional, VA) and adjust the down payment, rate and term.
What are the property taxes on 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE?+
The most recent tax bill on record (2021) was $3,458. A new owner's bill can differ once the sale price resets the assessed value — we can walk you through what to expect.
Are pets allowed at 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE?+
The listing reports pets: Breed Restrictions, Yes. Communities often layer on breed or weight rules — we'll verify the specifics with the association before you commit.
How does the price compare to other homes in Sarasota?+
At $5,500, this home is listed about 99% below the Sarasota median of $555,885. The market section on this page shows how the area is trending.
Which schools are assigned to 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE?+
Phillippi Shores Elementary School (elementary), Riverview High School (high), Brookside Middle School (middle) — Sarasota County School District. Always verify school assignments with the district before relying on them.
The brief
Four things that matter here
01Under the SARASOTA 34231 market on paper
$5,500 is 97% below the SARASOTA 34231 median of $207,000, and at $4/sqft it sits under the Sarasota average of $493.
02Your own pool
A private pool — the feature Florida buyers ask for first, already in the ground and included in the price.
03Time on market is leverage
4118 days on market against a Sarasota median of 64 — sellers in this position are usually ready to negotiate.
04Strong assigned schools
Phillippi Shores Elementary School, Riverview High School, Brookside Middle School — Phillippi Shores Elementary School rates 5 of 5. Always verify assignments with the district.
Keep looking
Similar homes nearby
Listing courtesy of JENNETTE PROPERTIES, INC. · Catherine Foley. MLS #A4121629.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by Stellar MLS.
Never miss a listing
New Sarasota homes, in your inbox
Like 5753 NEW YORK AVENUE but not quite? A daily digest of every new listing in Sarasota — straight from the MLS, hours after it goes live. Unsubscribe anytime.
Just watching this one home? Ask Krystina to ping you on any price or status change →