Bimini Bay Estates

It's one of Anna Maria Island's most established waterfront communities, with quiet streets, canal access, and pools on essentially every property. Families are assigned to Anna Maria Elementary School and Manatee High School, and downtown Tampa is about a 74-minute drive when you need the mainland. It suits buyers who want island privacy without giving up beach proximity.

Yes — this is a top-tier luxury market. Every active listing is priced above $1M, with a median list price of $5,935,000 and a range from $3,950,000 to $8,000,000. Expect roughly $1,612 per square foot for waterfront property here.

Active listings range from $3,950,000 to $8,000,000 with a median of $5,935,000, and the median home size is about 3,555 square feet. Over the past 12 months, the two homes that sold closed at a median of $3,190,000. You can see current inventory on the live map.

It's a slow, low-volume luxury market — only 2 homes sold in the last 12 months against 8 active listings. Properties sit a median of 233 days on market, and sellers are averaging 95% of asking, which leaves informed buyers real negotiating room. Neighboring pockets like Luana Isles offer additional options if inventory feels thin.

HOA data isn't currently available for the neighborhood, so budget on a per-property basis when you find a home you like. Property taxes are substantial given the price point — the median annual tax bill runs about $50,434, in line with waterfront Anna Maria values.