Bimini Bay Colony Club

It suits buyers who want island life at a slower, quieter pace on Anna Maria's north end, close to the Gulf and bayside waters. Families benefit from island-zoned schools including Anna Maria Elementary School, and downtown Tampa is roughly 74 minutes away when you need the mainland.

Yes — this is a premium island market, with the current active listing priced at $1,525,000 and an average of about $802 per square foot. Everything trading here recently has been in the $1M-plus range, so budget accordingly.

The single active listing is $1,525,000 for roughly 1,902 square feet, and the two homes sold in the past year closed at a median of $1,492,500. Because volume is so low, comparing against nearby Shore Acres and Bimini Bay Estates helps set expectations.

It's thin and slow-moving — one active listing, two sales in the last twelve months, and a median 83 days on market. Sellers have been getting about 94% of asking on average, so there's usually a little room to negotiate when a home comes up.

Median property tax here runs about $3,591 per year, which is reasonable given island price points. HOA figures aren't reported in the current data, so confirm any dues directly on the specific property you're considering.