Pinecraft

It's a quiet, exceptionally walkable neighborhood with a strong Amish and Mennonite identity that makes it feel distinct from the rest of Sarasota. If you value a slower, bicycle-oriented pace and a central location close to the beaches, it's a rare find. Assigned schools include Alta Vista Elementary, Brookside Middle, and Sarasota High.

It depends on which end of the market you're looking at. The one active listing is priced at $1,499,900, but the six homes sold over the past year had a median sold price of $429,625 — so most everyday transactions land far below that headline number. Values vary widely depending on the home.

Right now there's a single active listing at $1,499,900, which works out to roughly $1,095 per square foot on a compact 1,370-square-foot footprint. That's a high-end outlier compared to the neighborhood's $429,625 median sold price over the last year. Given how few homes trade here, expect prices to swing based on the individual property.

It's a thin, quick-turning market with just one active listing and six sales in the past twelve months. Well-priced homes move fast, with a median of 12 days on market and sellers averaging about 97% of their asking price. Because inventory is so limited, buyers who want in here should be ready to act when something lists — or look at nearby Arlington Park for more options.

There's no typical HOA fee reported for the neighborhood, which fits its older, non-planned character. The median annual property tax runs about $3,214, though your exact bill depends on the home's assessed value and any exemptions. Always confirm the specifics on a given property before you buy.